EMH question

CFIA mock exam morning session question 88 states that if a market violates semi-strong form, then it also violates weak-form.

How is this possible? I understand if market is semi-strong form, then it automatically is in weak form too. However, a market may not be in semi-strong form but still be in weak-form.

For example, Heineken cannot be whiskey(semi-strong) but can still be alcohol beverage(weak form).

They’re mistaken; you’re correct.

should I contact CFAI to fix it?

I had the same doubt as well. They corrected this in the errata.

http://www.cfainstitute.org/mycfa/candidate/resources/studyaids/practice/documents/2013_level_i_mock_exam_errata.pdf

looks like they finally fixed it. Last time I checked it wasn’t updated…