Sign up  |  Log in

Firms in peer group for analysis

I am unable to understand why A) is incorrect:

Q: An analyst should most likely include two firms in the same peer group for analysis if the firms:

a) are both grouped in the same industry classification

b) are similar in size, industry life-cycle stage and cyclicality

c) derive their revenues and earnings from similar business activities

OA is C. I was thinking that some part of AT&T’s (or say Comcast) revenue and whole part of Cisco’s  revenue come from selling hardware boxes. Does it mean that we should include them as peer? No because the answer choice doesn’t say “the primary source of revenue.” However, Industry classification could be a better measure because ATT and Cisco are in different industry classification. However, A) is incorrect. Can someone please explain this to me?

Make the most of your CFA® Progam prep in one weekend! Join renowned instructors Peter Olinto & David Hetherington in May for a live, two-day intensive final review class.

All 3 seem reasonable to me. Anyone care to chime in?

Yeah even I agree with you on the point that C is a bit sketchy.

But I think they are considering A as incorrect because 2 companies classified in a particular industry can have a huge difference in their sizes in terms of turnover or asset base. I feel that’s why A is considered as incorrect. 

In my honest opinion none of the 3 statements are full-proof. :P