Stock X: 15% overvalued

Stock Y: 10% overvalued

Stock Z: 15% undervalued

In orders to execute a pairs trading strategy, they said to use stocks Y and Z? How come it would not involve stock X and Z? They seem to offset each other (assuming the two stocks are in the same industry). Which I thought was required to take the long and short positions in the pairs trading strategy.

Make the most of your CFA® Progam prep in one weekend! Join renowned instructors, Peter Olinto, Darren Degraaf & David Hetherington in May for a live, two-day intensive final review class.

Hi,

did anyone get an answer on this topic. I have the same problem. Probably (not sure) because X and Z were off setting each other 0 return seems not the best choice.

Thanks!

keep_running wrote:

Stock X: 15% overvalued

Stock Y: 10% overvalued

Stock Z: 15% undervalued

In orders to execute a pairs trading strategy, they said to use stocks Y and Z? How come it would not involve stock X and Z? They seem to offset each other (assuming the two stocks are in the same industry). Which I thought was required to take the long and short positions in the pairs trading strategy.

I believe, there are lot of assumptions going on here.

If you involve X and Z and X goes down by 5% and Z goes up by 5% then net profit might not be much (assuming that all these stocks are in the same industry and their current stock prices are very similar)

Also X has the potential to go down by maximum 15% and Z has the potential to go up by maximum 15% if we assume that their market prices will converge to their intrinsic values over the same period of time, and it doesn’t give us much profit in this Pair Trading Scenario.

However, if you use Y and Z, then it can offer a much large potential gain compared to when we use X and Z, when the prices of Y and Z moves by the same amount, converging to their intrinsic values.

Hope, it makes sense. This is just my understanding, however, I might be wrong here.

Where is this question from?

For the most recent poster this question is taken from the EOC, reading 26, question 20.

The reason the answer is C, which is buy Z and short Y is because the other 2 multiple choice answers are definitely incorrect. If Buying Y and selling X was an option, I believe it would be the ‘most’ likely answer but in this case the ‘most’ likely answer is Buying Z and selling Y.

For context , the three options were

1)  sell X and Y