Essay questions on "picking a portfolio"

On these questions, I notice that they say pick the correct portfolio, and then justify it with x amount of reasons, or in regards to areas of the IPS. Now my question is, do we need to simply justify our choice, or do we also need to explain why the others are not suitable? They seem to do both in the sample answers, but the question isn’t asking us for that in my interpretation.

i guess just write whatever is asked for. No extra credit for additional stuff

I think jut111 is asking if one should justify the choice by saying why a particular portfolio was chosen OR by syaing why the others should not be chosen. Based on what I’ve seen, either way is appropriate.

they usually ask you state why others should not be selected. If they don’t ask then don’t write.

cool, sounds like a RTFQ issue.