wake2000 Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > I would rank em as follows: > > Manning > Brady > Rodgers > Brees > Rivers > Rapeslisburger > Ryan > Schaub > Romo I agree with this ranking. I think Roethlisberger is definitely overrated by many due to 2 or three drives that everyone saw on national TV. He has a lot of game winning dives, but he’s also had a lot of big come-from-behind situations. He’s not a great quarterback on a consistent basis.
I think Manning, Brady, Rogers, and Rivers are clearly above Roth, the others like Romo, Brees, Schaub are probably comparable. Sorry Mphoenix, Michael Vick and Vince Young don’t belong in this discussion.
There is no way Tony Homo should be on any sort of best quarterbacks list.
I’d take Vick over romo. He’ll win a sb in the 5 years I think as he continues to develop.
In all fairness, Vick plays on a team that is more likely to win a super bowl in 5 years. The Eagles are always in the hunt while the Cowboys can’t get out of their own way. At least Cowboys stadium is really nice. jcole21 Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > I’d take Vick over romo. He’ll win a sb in the 5 > years I think as he continues to develop.
^ I have a friend that visited over 250 sports stadiums across multiple sports across the world, and he says the new Cowboy stadium is the best he’s seen so far.
murders&executions Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > In all fairness, Vick plays on a team that is more > likely to win a super bowl in 5 years. > The Eagles are always in the hunt while the > Cowboys can’t get out of their own way. At least > Cowboys stadium is really nice. > > jcole21 Wrote: > -------------------------------------------------- > ----- > > I’d take Vick over romo. He’ll win a sb in the > 5 > > years I think as he continues to develop. True true.
jcole21 Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > I’d take Vick over romo. He’ll win a sb in the 5 > years I think as he continues to develop. Not if he is still an Eagle. Jeff Lurie’s primary goal is making money, not winning championships. He will not surround Vick, or any QB, with the talent needed to win because that cuts into the bottom line. They made it to the NFC championship and the SB in the past because of a great defense built on inexpensive but talented players and run by a great defensive coordinator. They don’t have either of those ingredients now.
Manning’s brother should be in the discussion as well and take out h omo
former trader Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > ^ I have a friend that visited over 250 sports > stadiums across multiple sports across the world, > and he says the new Cowboy stadium is the best > he’s seen so far. Nothing is better than Camp Nou - especially after it is remodelled.
wake2000 Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > Manning’s brother should be in the discussion as > well and take out h omo You’re funny.
wake2000 Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > Manning’s brother should be in the discussion as > well and take out h omo The only reason I didn’t include Manning is his on field demeanor. There is no more annoying player in football. He’s the Tim Duncan of the NFL.
Mark Sanchez.
therapists