^ There is more than economics to sovereignty. Quebec would undoubtedly be economically disadvantaged by separation, but it doesn’t mean they’d be less happy. Alberta should flip you all the bird, maybe taking BC along. Now that’s a separation that would be a huge economic advantage and makes cultural sense (Calgary and Edmonton are more different culturally from Toronto than Montreal is).
Scotland reminds me of 1999 when Australia had their big referendum to become a republic. I think it was 55 no to 45 yes in the end, but a couple of states were very very close. Interest in becoming a republic in Australia has waned in recent years with the new royals (William and Kate) and their popularity.
as long as you take all the Quebec and Ontario provincial debt with you, it’s a deal. haha. confederation is like a marriage, when you split, the high earner is responsible for all the spender’s debt.
and that separation would involve cutting the world’s 2nd largest country into 3 parts. at which point, you may as well make every province its own country.
We should weight Canada’s area by several categories. First of all, some 10% of Canada is over water. Not counting water, the US would in fact cover more area than Canada. Second, large parts of Canada are undesirable or unsuitable for dense populations. Any equitable division of land should account for usability of land within each partition.
If I was the King of Canada, I would immediately order every Canadian to buy Hummers and burn all the fossil fuels they can find. This will expedite climate change and help transform Canada into a suitable area for agriculture and human population.
A share of the national debt proportional to population, sure. But provincial debts? Good luck. I have sympathy for Quebec, they’re weird and socialist but their intentions are good (beyond corruption issues). Ontario is just a mismanaged political disaster. I don’t think there is a less competent government in the western world. And it was re-elected!!! Ontario has no one to blame but themselves for their financial hole.